The two had also become involved with Leib Tropper, a New York-area rabbi who held ultra-Orthodox beliefs. Tropper said that the only person who could allow somebody to convert to Judaism was a rabbi who did not believe that the universe predated the Jewish calendar, according to Tablet. A foundation in memory of Kaplan's deceased mother, administrated by Aguiar from his Fort Lauderdale home, paid millions to Tropper's business venture, supporting his strict beliefs; court filings show that Tropper wanted more. Later, Aguiar moved to Jerusalem and bought a soccer team with his insane wealth from the oilfields.
In December 2009, the New York Post, following a scoop by the Failed Messiah blog, revealed a seamy tape recording of Tropper, Aguiar's beneficiary, trying to get a Houston woman named Shannon Orand to have sex with his buddies in exchange for his blessing of her attempted conversion to Judaism. From the Post:
Tropper, who calls the woman "darling" and "cutie pie," talks about his own love affair with her at one point, saying: "I want to squeeze you."
He also fantasized about rape. "I could role-play a rape with you but I couldn't actually rape you -- you know what I'm saying, darling -- does that make sense?" he asks.
A month later, Aguiar went off to the mental institution, for apparently unrelated reasons. His own notoriety and story -- an evangelical Christian turned playboy Zionist -- attracts rumor and speculation, especially after he's disappeared. With each strange connection he left behind, there's another question about why he vanished. The hunt for Aguiar continues even though the Coast Guard has called off its search. We'll be taking a few more excursions into his past over the coming days.