Brooklyn Man Charged with Hate Crime Against Neighbor: MyFoxNY.com
A boozy Brooklyn man was hit with hate crime charges Sunday for pouring beer on a newlywed neighbor, calling her an "Arab terrorist" and pummeling her husband, police sources said.
Following the seemingly unprovoked attack Saturday night in Mill Basin, Simchon Schwartz, 46, hid in a local synagogue and tried to fight off cops when they came to arrest him, sources said.
The Hasid even kicked out a window of a police cruiser as he sat inside, whining that "the cuffs are too tight," a source said.
"F---ing Arabs! F---ing terrorists!" Schwartz screamed when he grabbed his neighbor, Selda Turan, 27. He shoved the woman against her car and poured beer on her head, a police source said.
Turan's husband of 13 months, Mustafa Turan, rushed out of their house to protect his wife, but Schwartz punched him in the face, the source said.
Neighbors said the Turans moved into the heavily Jewish neighborhood about a month ago. They said the victims were from Turkey; it wasn't clear if they were Muslim.
Schwartz was arraigned in Brooklyn Criminal Court on charges of felony assault and felony criminal mischief, both as hate crimes. He was also charged with resisting arrest, obstructing cops, menacing and harassment. He could get up to 15 years in prison if convicted.
"They arrested the wrong person," Schwartz's attorney, Lance Lazzaro, said Monday night.
He said his client was attacked by Mustafa Turan, 32, after Selda Turan complained about Schwartz's children being noisy. He said Mustafa Turan called Schwartz a "dirty Jew" and hit him.
Cops said they found no physical evidence supporting Schwartz's counterclaim, while Mustafa Turan needed three stitches to close a gash on his nose. The ordeal erupted at 7 p.m. Saturday when Schwartz began harassing Selda Turan on their E. 70th St. block, a criminal complaint charges. Schwartz opened a can of beer and poured it on Selda Turan, grabbed her by the the arm, pushed her into the side of her car and called her an "Arab terrorist," the complaint said.
Selda Turan was left with scratches and bruises. Schwartz was released without bail.
A judge rejected a prosecution request to hold Schwartz on $60,000 bail, but granted the Turans an order of protection barring him from contacting them.
The Turkish couple live in a townhouse that shares a common wall with Schwartz's home.
Cops said that following the fisticuffs, Schwartz scratched the Turans' car with a key.
Once Schwartz, a car dealer, bolted from the scene, the Turans called 911. Schwartz's son led cops to a Chabad House on nearby E. 69th St., where they found the suspect. Cops smelled alcohol on his breath, a source said.
Schwartz struggled with cops as they dragged him out of the synagogue in handcuffs. They drove him to his house, where his neighbors identified him as the culprit. As Schwartz threw a tantrum in the police car, his wife made a veiled threat to the victims, sources said.
"This is a majority Jewish neighborhood. We're going to get you back," Esther Schwartz told the Turans, the sources said.
While Schwartz was in jail over the weekend, his wife circulated a petition demanding the Turans' landlord evict them, neighbors said. About 20 neighbors signed it, but the Turans' landlords, Rusden and Saadet Dolan, refused.
----------------------------------------------
Mayhem erupted outside a multi-family Brooklyn home over the weekend leaving this diverse block stunned. It all started with a dispute over noise and ended with an Israeli man charged with hate crimes against his Turkish neighbor, police say.
Police sources say Israeli businessman Simchon Schwartz, 46, confronted his 26-year-old Turkish neighbor, Selda Turan, calling her an Arab terrorist while pouring beer on her. Cops say when her husband, Mustafa Turan, tried to rescue her, Schwartz punched him in the nose.
Schwatrz is Jewish, but it is not clear if the Turans are Muslim.
While Schwartz was cuffed in the squad car, he was screaming and kicked out the window, police say.
Schwartz's daughter, Mazo, and her Albanian Muslim boyfriend told Fox 5 that Schwartz does not hate anyone and that cops have it all wrong.
Sources close to the case said Schwartz bragged that cops grabbed him because he beat his neighbor up worse, but police weren't impressed with his punching prowess. Cops arrested him for hate crime assault and other charges. He is free without bail.
His Turkish neighbors were granted an order of protection.
---------------------------------------------------------
A drunken Hasidic Jewish man who assaulted his Turkish neighbour - pouring beer on her and calling her a 'terrorist' - hid in a synagogue and tried to fight policemen when they came to arrest him, sources said.
Simchon Schwartz, 46, is said to have kicked out a window of a police patrol car as he sat inside, complaining his handcuffs were 'too tight'.
According to police sources, Schwartz screamed [expletive] Arabs! [expletive] terrorists!', when he grabbed neighbor, Selda Turan, 27.
He then shoved the 32-year-old woman against her car, opened a can of beer and poured it on her head.
When her husband rushed out of the house to protect his wife he was punched in the face by Schwartz.
Schwartz's fled to the synagogue on nearby E. 69th St., while the Turan's called the police.
When they arrived Schartz's son led them to his father's hiding place.
Cops smelled alcohol on his breath, a source said.
He was driven back to his house, where the Turan's neighbours identified him as the culprit.
Sources have reported that Schwartz's wife made a veiled threat to the victims, sources said.
'This is a majority Jewish neighborhood. We're going to get you back,' Esther Schwartz told the Turans, the sources said.
Neighbours in the predominantley Jewish neighborhood say the Turans, who are from Turkey, moved into the area about a month ago.
it isn't clear if they are Muslim.
Car dealer Schwartz is facing up to 15 years in prison if convicted.
He appeared in Brooklyn Criminal Court where he was arraigned on charges of felony assault and felony criminal mischief, both as hate crimes.
He was also charged with resisting arrest, obstructing cops, menacing and harassment.
His attorney Lance Lazzaro said: 'They arrested the wrong person.'
Lazzaro claims Schwartz was attacked by Mrs Turnan's husband Mustafa Turan, 32, after she had complained about Schwartz's children.
He said Mr Turan called Schwartz a 'dirty Jew' before hitting him.
But police say they found no physical evidence supporting Schwartz's accusations while Mustafa Turan had suffered facial injuries.
I thought Hasid jews cannot drink alcohol??
ReplyDeleteReleased without bail? Interesting?!?! Had this been a black, hispanic or maybe even a white man, there would've been some amount of bail needed to be posted. What a POS judge!!!
ReplyDeleteYou gotta love that Headline. You have to ask, could the headline also have read Brooklyn Christian charged with felony? if he had been a christian.
ReplyDeleteThis report understates things a bit. According to regular news sources he smashed the man's wife's head into a car before pouring beer on her. He started beating the man and shrieking obscenities related to his ethnicity. Then he ran into a shul and attacked the cops when they came to arrest him.
ReplyDeleteIt wasn't just a little harmless name calling. According to the official reports it was an all-out crazy assault complete with flight, resisting arrest and assaulting police officers.
Wow... a Jewish man made "harmful" comments to his neighbour (who allegedly made harmful comments first). That and the occasional welfare cheat.
ReplyDeletePlease compare that with minority neighborhoods that are inundated with murder, rape, violence, prostitution and drug dealings. People smoking crack and skipping school. Fighting over silly things like "shoes".
Its interesting to note that Jewish neighborhoods, statistically, ALMOST ALWAYS have less crime than others.
The fact that you guys have to latch on to this isolated incident is pathetic
Anyone else would have been held without bail for a hate crime, fighting with police and destroying police property.
ReplyDeleteIf you live in a neighborhood and don't pay taxes, live in town houses at taxpayers expense, feed your family with food stamps and pay your bills with tax payer dollars, are exempt from military duty, why commit crimes, you have no need to.
ReplyDeleteAll one can say.Why is this attacker not in jail.
ReplyDeleteno mater the religious orientation.A crime is a
crime.Who is in charge of this police?