A Brooklyn yeshiva got a costly lesson in civics when it was tossed from a national contest -- and lost a $500,000 prize -- for allegedly cheating.
United Lubavitcher Yeshiva was one of 20 schools selected to share $10 million put up by the Kohl's department-store chain as part of a back-to-school contest. People were asked to vote online for a deserving school that could put a half-million dollars to good use.
More than 11 million votes were cast, with parents and educators nationwide working feverishly to drum up support for their schools. The 600-boy elementary school on 570 Crown St. came in 18th, with 139,246 votes, according to Kohl's Facebook fan page.
WINNERS LOSE: How yeshiva boosted votes.
But the Chabad yeshiva in Crown Heights was unceremoniously bounced from the Top 20 after the chain's auditor disqualified a chunk of its votes when the "Kohl's Cares" contest ended Sept. 3.
In a bid to lure voters, the yeshiva raffled off an iPod and even created a Web site to tout the raffle. It explained that people who got five others to vote for the school would get additional raffle tickets.
Shmarya Rosenberg, who writes the popular Jewish blog failedmessiah.com and has been a frequent critic of the Chabad movement of the Lubavitch Hasidim, also charged that the yeshiva broke the rules by buying votes from a so-called "vote broker."
"The schools would pay him money based on how many votes he delivered. He could get people from outside the country to vote for the school," said Rosenberg, referring to a broker he spoke with but would not identify.
The yeshiva denies it cheated. "We have contacted Kohl's to find out why we were disqualified and have yet to hear back from them," said a school administrator who asked to remain anonymous. The school is contemplating legal action, he added.
Kohl's, which has already doled out the prize money, declined to say why it knocked three schools from the Top 20.
A public school in Northridge, Calif., and a Chabad school in Worcester, Mass., were also disqualified.
R' Yingy Bistritzky
ReplyDeleteim wondering how come yingy bistizky mixes into every crime that happens in crown heights?????????????????
ReplyDeleteDamn, payback is a bitch. This is what happens to a school that continues to employ sorry excuses for teachers. Teachers that are verbally & emotionally abusive to children. Parents complain all day long but they refuse to make changes. I don't feel sorry for their shame.
ReplyDeleteWell rules are rules. Chabad is going to charge this as an anti Semitic decision and play victim again.
ReplyDeleteno reason to be disqualified they have to pay up they made a agreement and they need to keep to it they shouldve thought first before they made a commitment in this economy
ReplyDeleteIt's pretty sad that people are blaming Kohls.
ReplyDeleteDo you understand that the United Lubavitcher Yeshiva and the Worcester School got caught cheating?
Do you understand that these school bought votes to bring them to the top twenty schools?
Kohls removed the fake votes and these schools were no longer in the top twenty.
The also removed one public school for the same offense.
Claiming that everything is anti-semitism makes my stomach turn.
There are a lot of yeshivas that played by the rules and got checks for Kohls.
And United Lubavitcher Yeshiva isn't suing ANYONE. They got caught.
Chazir Kosher Fissel anyone?
They're doing it again. They just cheated in the Chase Giveaway using the same scam. They paid me .21 cents for the vote through InvisionCA's scammy swapbucks and easycash! programs. http://nopostergirl.com/2011/05/25/cheating-in-chase-community-giving/ Please help share the Kohl's story again so they can be properly DQ'd!
ReplyDelete